Amazon Basics vs. Staples: Which Shredder Is Right for Your Home Office?
Don't let a pile of sensitive documents become a security risk waiting to happen.
A good shredder isn’t just about destroying paper; it’s about security, convenience, and capacity. The best models balance shredding power and run time without constant jamming or overheating, while lesser shredders quit after just a few minutes, leaving you with a half-finished job.
- Manual Power vs. Automated Convenience The Amazon Basics shredder excels at manual, high-volume tasks with its long run time, while the Staples model offers set-it-and-forget-it convenience with its large autofeed tray.
- Security Matters Staples’ micro-cut technology provides significantly higher security (P-4) than Amazon’s cross-cut (P-3), making it a better choice for highly sensitive documents.
- Pay for Time-Saving Features The price difference is substantial. You’re paying a premium for the Staples shredder’s time-saving autofeed feature and superior security level.
- Match the Shredder to Your Habits If you save up shredding for one big session, the Amazon Basics is ideal. If you shred small amounts frequently, the Staples autofeed will be a more practical daily tool.
Best Overall: Amazon Basics 18 Sheet Cross Cut Paper, CD, and Credit Card Shredder
Handle large shredding jobs without interruption thanks to its impressive 30-minute continuous run time. Its 18-sheet capacity and cross-cut action ma
- Exceptionally long 30-minute continuous run time
- High 18-sheet capacity for a manual feeder
- Powers through credit cards, CDs, and staples
- Great performance for a budget-friendly price
- Cross-cut offers lower security than micro-cut
- Requires manual feeding for all jobs
- Can be loud during heavy use
Runner Up: Staples 150-Sheet Micro-Cut Paper Shredder
Save time by loading up to 150 sheets for automatic shredding. Its P-4 micro-cut technology provides superior security, turning documents into tiny, u
- Autofeed tray is a massive time-saver
- Micro-cut provides excellent security for sensitive files
- Large pull-out bin means less frequent emptying
- Relatively quiet during autofeed operation
- Significantly more expensive
- Shorter continuous run time for manual shredding
- Lower manual sheet capacity than the Amazon model
Side-by-side comparison
|
Best Overall
Amazon Basics 18 Sheet Cross Cut Paper, CD, and Cr
|
Runner Up
Staples 150-Sheet Micro-Cut Paper Shredder, Autofe
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
| Security Level | Cross-Cut (P-3) | Micro-Cut (P-4) |
| Primary Feed Type | Manual (18 sheets) | Autofeed (150 sheets) |
| Continuous Run Time | 30 minutes | 10 minutes |
| Bin Capacity | 6 Gallons | 7.4 Gallons |
| Price | $108.00 | $262.99 |
| BUY NOW | BUY NOW |
What to look for in Home Shredders
What's the real-world difference between cross-cut and micro-cut?
Think of it this way: with cross-cut, you get short, fat strips. With enough time, a determined person could potentially piece some information together. With micro-cut, you get tiny, confetti-like particles. Reconstructing a document from micro-cut shreds is practically impossible, offering far superior peace of mind for sensitive data.
Is an autofeed shredder really worth the extra money?
If you dread shredding because it means standing over a machine feeding in a few pages at a time, then yes. An autofeed shredder like the Staples model lets you load a stack, press a button, and walk away. It turns a tedious chore into a background task, saving you a significant amount of active time.
Can I really shred for 30 minutes straight with the Amazon Basics model?
Yes, its main selling point is its endurance. It’s designed for users who save up their shredding and want to get it all done in one session. While performance can vary slightly based on paper thickness and staples, it reliably handles long shredding jobs that would cause most other shredders in its price range to overheat.
Can both of these shredders handle staples and credit cards?
The Amazon Basics model is explicitly designed to shred credit cards, CDs, and paper with staples. The Staples autofeed model is designed to handle staples and credit cards through its manual feed slot, but you should never put credit cards or CDs in the autofeed tray.
The bottom line
- Amazon Basics 18 Sheet Shredder: Get this if you want a powerful, no-frills workhorse for tackling large piles of paper in one go and are comfortable with standard cross-cut security.
- Staples 150-Sheet Shredder: Get this if you value your time, need high-level security, and prefer to load a stack of documents and walk away.
Your choice comes down to your shredding style and budget. Both are excellent shredders that serve different needs. The Amazon Basics shredder is a powerful tool for manual batch shredding, while the Staples shredder offers automated convenience and higher security.
