Why Homemade Ice Cream Is Always Better
The difference between freshly churned, homemade ice cream and a tub from the freezer aisle is night and day.
A great ice cream maker creates a silky-smooth texture by continuously churning a base as it freezes, preventing large ice crystals. The primary choice is between compressor models, which are ready anytime, and freezer-bowl models, which require planning but offer great value. Understanding this trade-off is the first step to frozen dessert perfection.
- Compressor vs. Freezer Bowl Compressor models let you make ice cream spontaneously, while freezer-bowl models are cheaper but require you to pre-freeze the bowl for 12-24 hours.
- Capacity Is Fairly Standard Most home models, regardless of price, have a 1.5-quart capacity, which yields about 10-12 scoops. This is plenty for a family dessert.
- Specialty Functions Add Versatility Some machines offer specific paddles for gelato, which is denser, or have attachments for creating authentic soft serve, complete with mix-in dispensers.
- Price Buys Convenience, Not Quality An affordable freezer-bowl model can make ice cream just as delicious as a premium compressor unit. You are paying for spontaneity, automation, and build quality.
Best Overall: Cuisinart 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker and Gelato Machine, ICE-100
Its built-in compressor means no pre-freezing is needed, so you can make batch after batch. Includes separate paddles for perfect ice cream and authen
- No pre-freezing required for the bowl
- Can make multiple batches back-to-back
- Separate paddles optimize texture for gelato and ice cream
- 10-minute keep-cool function maintains temperature after churning
- Heavier and larger than freezer bowl models
- Significantly more expensive than non-compressor units
- Churning process can be noisy
Best Premium: Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker BCI600XL
The first ice cream maker to automatically sense mixture hardness. It has 12 presets from sorbet to ice cream and keeps it cool for up to 3 hours.
- Automatic hardness sensor removes all guesswork
- Pre-cool function significantly speeds up the process
- Impressive 3-hour keep-cool feature is incredibly effective
- High-end stainless steel construction
- Extremely expensive for a home appliance
- Very heavy and requires significant counter space
- More complex than most casual users will ever need
Best Value: Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, 1.5 Quart Double Insulated, ICE-21P1
Makes delicious frozen desserts in 20 minutes or less. The double-insulated freezer bowl eliminates the need for ice, offering a simple and fast proce
- Incredible performance for a very low price
- Extremely simple one-switch operation
- Lightweight and relatively easy to store
- Produces excellent, smooth ice cream if you plan ahead
- Bowl requires 12-24 hours of pre-freezing
- Can only make one batch until the bowl is re-frozen
- The large bowl takes up significant freezer space
Best for Soft Serve: Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, 1.5 Quart Mix It In Soft Serve, ICE-45P1
Create an authentic soft-serve experience at home. This machine dispenses creamy swirls and has three built-in containers for your favorite mix-ins.
- Dispenses real soft-serve ice cream
- Built-in dispensers for sprinkles and toppings are great for kids
- Easy to assemble and fun to use
- Relatively affordable for a specialty machine
- Uses a freezer bowl that requires pre-freezing
- Dispensing mechanism can be messy to clean thoroughly
- Limited to making soft-serve style desserts only
Side-by-side comparison
|
Best Overall
Cuisinart 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker and Gelato Mac
|
Best Premium
Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker BCI600XL, Bru
|
Best Value
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, 1.5 Quart Double Insula
|
Best for Soft Serve
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker Machine, 1.5 Quart Mix I
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Type | Compressor | Compressor | Freezer Bowl | Freezer Bowl (Soft Serve) |
| Pre-Freezing Required? | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Keep Cool Function? | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Capacity (Quarts) | 1.5 /10 | 1.5 /10 | 1.5 /10 | 1.5 /10 |
| Price | $379.95 | $599.95 | $69.95 | $192.13 |
| BUY NOW | BUY NOW | BUY NOW | BUY NOW |
What to look for in Ice Cream Makers
Is a compressor ice cream maker worth the extra money?
If you plan to make ice cream frequently (weekly) or want to make multiple different flavors in one day for a party, then yes. The ability to start making ice cream on a whim without any prep is a game-changer. For occasional use, a much cheaper freezer-bowl model will produce equally delicious results.
What's the difference between ice cream and gelato?
Gelato has a higher proportion of milk to cream and is churned at a slower speed, incorporating less air. This results in a denser, silkier, and often more intensely flavored product. Some machines, like our top pick, come with a specific gelato paddle that churns more slowly.
How long does homemade ice cream last in the freezer?
Homemade ice cream is best eaten within a few hours of churning for the best texture. It can be stored in an airtight container in the freezer for 1-2 weeks, but its texture will degrade over time as ice crystals form. It will not last as long as commercial ice cream which contains stabilizers.
Do I need to 'harden' my ice cream after churning?
Yes. Freshly churned ice cream has the consistency of soft serve. For a firm, scoopable texture, you need to transfer it to an airtight container and place it in your freezer for at least 2-4 hours to ‘harden’ or ‘ripen’.
The bottom line
- Cuisinart ICE-100: The best all-arounder for serious home users who want compressor convenience and great results.
- Breville Smart Scoop: An incredible, automated machine for perfectionists with a limitless budget.
- Cuisinart ICE-21P1: The unbeatable value choice that proves you don't need to spend a lot for fantastic homemade ice cream.
- Cuisinart ICE-45P1: The perfect pick for families who specifically want the fun and unique experience of at-home soft serve.
For most people, the decision comes down to convenience versus cost. The Cuisinart ICE-100 offers the ultimate convenience of a compressor without a ridiculous price tag, making it our top pick. However, for a fraction of the price, the Cuisinart ICE-21P1 makes ice cream that is just as delicious, provided you can remember to freeze the bowl ahead of time.
