OXO POP 10-Piece vs 5-Piece Set: Which Is Better?

The OXO 10-Piece Set is the definitive winner for kitchen organization because it includes the 4.4-quart and 2.8-quart sizes necessary for standard five-pound bags of flour and sugar. In our testing, we found the 5-Piece set lacks the volume for bulk baking staples. Choose the 10-piece set for full pantry overhauls.

Both sets use OXO’s signature push-button airtight seal mechanism—a silicone gasket that expands to block air when compressed—but they serve entirely different organization stages.

Most Containers

OXO Good Grips 10-Piece POP Container Set

Get double the containers for a complete pantry organization system.

9.1/10

EXPERT SCORE

Tackle your entire pantry with this 10-piece set. You get a wide variety of sizes, including a large 4.4 Qt container ideal for cereal and pasta, plus smaller ones for coffee and spices. The push-button airtight seal keeps food fresh, and all containers are dishwasher safe. Note that this set does not include any POP accessories.

View Price at Amazon.com View Price at Amazon.com

OXO Good Grips 10-Piece POP Container Set

I tested the 10-piece set by completely decanting my baking shelf. The inclusion of the massive 4.4-quart container solved my biggest headache: it comfortably fits a full five-pound bag of flour with an inch to spare below the fill line. The assortment ranges down to 0.4-quart blocks for spices or baking soda. The plastic walls feel rigid, and running them through the dishwasher’s bottom rack did not warp the containers or degrade the silicone seals during my testing.