Takeya vs. Ninja: A Head-to-Head Cold Brew Showdown
Stop overpaying for cold brew and decide if you need a dedicated brewer or a multi-function powerhouse.
We’re comparing two very different approaches to chilled coffee: the slow-and-steady Takeya immersion brewer and the fast-and-frosty Ninja blender. One offers smooth, low-acid concentrate, while the other delivers instant iced coffee gratification. The right choice depends entirely on your coffee habits, patience, and counter space.
- Takeya for Purists If you want true, smooth, low-acid cold brew concentrate, the Takeya is the simple, effective, and affordable choice.
- Ninja for Speed & Versatility The Ninja doesn’t make traditional cold brew; it makes iced coffee and frozen drinks in seconds and handles other kitchen tasks.
- Process Matters Takeya uses a 12-24 hour cold water immersion process. The Ninja uses high-speed blending with ice for an instant chill.
- Cost vs. Function The Takeya is a single-purpose, budget-friendly tool. The Ninja is a pricier, multi-functional kitchen appliance.
Best Overall: Takeya Tritan Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Enjoy smooth, less acidic coffee with this dedicated cold brew maker. Its fine-mesh filter ensures no grounds get in your drink, and the airtight pitc
- Extremely easy to use and clean
- Airtight seal keeps coffee fresh for up to two weeks
- Produces very smooth, low-acid coffee concentrate
- Durable build and slim design fits in a fridge door
- Requires 12-24 hours of brewing time
- Fine mesh filter can be tricky to clean of all grounds
- Only makes about four servings of concentrate at a time
Runner Up: Ninja BL660 Professional Compact Blender
Instantly create iced coffee and frozen drinks with this powerful 1100W blender. Its Total Crushing Blades turn ice to snow in seconds for a quick, fr
- Creates iced coffee in under a minute
- Extremely versatile for smoothies, sauces, and more
- Powerful motor pulverizes ice into snow
- Large capacity for making multiple servings at once
- Does not make true cold brew concentrate
- Very loud during operation
- Takes up significant counter and storage space
Side-by-side comparison
|
Best Overall
Takeya Tritan Cold Brew Coffee Maker – Airtight Pi
|
Runner Up
Ninja BL660 Professional Compact Smoothie & Food P
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
| Coffee Type | True Cold Brew Concentrate | Iced Coffee / Frozen Drinks |
| Time to Drink | 12-24 Hours | < 1 Minute |
| Versatility | Coffee Only | Coffee, Smoothies, Sauces, etc. |
| Footprint | Small (Fits in fridge door) | Large (Countertop appliance) |
| Price | $13.19 | $139.99 |
| BUY NOW | BUY NOW |
What to look for in Takeya vs. Ninja Cold Brew: Which Coffee Maker Is Right for You?
Can the Ninja make real cold brew?
No. The Ninja BL660 makes iced coffee by blending hot coffee with ice, or by creating coffee-flavored frozen drinks. True cold brew is made by steeping grounds in cold water for an extended period, which creates a different chemical profile and taste.
How much coffee does the 1-quart Takeya make?
The 1-quart model produces about 32 ounces of cold brew concentrate. You typically dilute this concentrate with water, milk, or ice at a 1:1 or 1:2 ratio, so one batch can yield 64-96 ounces of drinkable coffee, or about 8-12 servings.
Is the Takeya hard to clean?
The pitcher and lid are very easy to clean and are top-rack dishwasher-safe. The fine-mesh filter requires a bit more attention; tapping out the wet grounds and then rinsing it thoroughly from the outside-in is the most effective cleaning method.
Is the Ninja blender loud?
Yes, with an 1100-watt motor designed to crush ice, the Ninja is quite loud during operation. It’s a quick process that lasts less than a minute, but it’s not a quiet appliance like the silent, steeping Takeya.
The bottom line
- Takeya Tritan Cold Brew Coffee Maker: Get this if you want a simple, affordable, and effective way to make true, low-acid cold brew concentrate.
- Ninja BL660 Professional Blender: Get this if you want instant iced coffee and a powerful, versatile blender for smoothies and other kitchen tasks.
Your choice comes down to process and patience. The Takeya is the clear winner for making authentic, smooth cold brew concentrate on a budget. The Ninja offers instant gratification for iced coffee and serves as a multi-purpose kitchen workhorse, but it doesn’t actually make cold brew.
