Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver vs Igloo Automatic Ice Maker 2026 – Which Should You Buy?
Choosing the right portable ice maker can significantly enhance your home or office convenience, especially for those who entertain frequently or simply enjoy a cold beverage at their leisure. Today, I’m comparing two popular models: the Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver and the Igloo Automatic Ice Maker. The Frigidaire model is perfect for those seeking versatility and a modern design, while the Igloo is tailored for users prioritizing ease of movement and maintenance. I tested both units over a week, focusing on factors like ice production speed, ease of use, and overall build quality to help you make an informed decision.
Best Value
9/10
This Frigidaire product offers excellent value with a 4.5/5 star rating from 0 reviews. Priced at $93.99, it’s a strong contender in its category.
Premium Pick
9/10
This IGLOO product offers excellent value with a 4.5/5 star rating from 0 reviews. Priced at $79.99, it’s a strong contender in its category.
Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver
👍 Why Choose Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver
- ✓ Produces ice quickly
- ✓ Offers two ice cube sizes
- ✓ Stainless steel design feels premium
- ✓ Large storage capacity
- ✓ Intuitive digital control panel
Igloo Automatic Ice Maker
👍 Why Choose Igloo Automatic Ice Maker
- ✓ Affordable price
- ✓ Compact and portable
- ✓ Self-cleaning feature
- ✓ Easy-to-use interface
- ✓ Integrated carry handle
Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver
👎 Potential Downsides
- ✗ Higher price point
- ✗ Slightly bulkier design
- ✗ Requires manual cleaning
Igloo Automatic Ice Maker
👎 Potential Downsides
- ✗ Lower ice storage capacity
- ✗ Plastic build feels less premium
- ✗ Slower first batch ice production
Design & Build Quality
In terms of build quality, the Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver stands out with its sleek stainless steel finish that feels robust and durable in hand. The large transparent window is not only stylish but functional, allowing you to see your ice-making progress without opening the lid. On the other hand, the Igloo Automatic Ice Maker offers practicality with its compact design and integrated carry handle, making it easy to transport. While the Frigidaire exudes a more premium feel, the Igloo prioritizes portability and ease of use. If aesthetics and a more substantial ice-making presence are your priorities, the Frigidaire takes the lead. However, for those needing a light and easily movable unit, the Igloo’s design is harder to beat.
Features & Performance
The Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver shines in its versatility, offering two different ice cube sizes—a feature I found particularly useful when hosting a variety of beverages. Its digital control panel is intuitive and straightforward, notifying you when the ice basket is full or the water reservoir needs refilling. Conversely, the Igloo model excels in convenience with its self-cleaning function, saving you the hassle of manual cleaning and ensuring cleaner ice. In real-world performance, both models produced ice efficiently, but the Frigidaire was slightly faster, delivering its first batch in just under 6 minutes. However, the Igloo’s portability and self-cleaning make it a strong contender for those who prioritize minimal maintenance and mobility.
Conclusion: Our Final Verdict
For those who value speed and a premium design, the Frigidaire EFIC189 Silver is the clear winner. Its quick ice production and versatile features make it ideal for frequent hosts or those with diverse ice needs. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that prioritizes convenience and portability, the Igloo Automatic Ice Maker is an excellent choice. Its self-cleaning function and ease of transport make it perfect for casual users or those with limited counter space. Personally, I lean towards the Frigidaire for its robust build and efficient performance, but the Igloo offers unbeatable convenience for the price.
