The My Weigh KD-8000 registers a single gram of yeast instantly, while the OXO Good Grips 11-pound scale often needs a three-gram pile before the screen wakes up. I spent a week testing both scales with heavy glass bowls and messy ingredients. You want the OXO for a clean countertop and basic meal prep. You need the My Weigh if you bake bread by the gram and demand absolute precision.
Best Value
9/10
The OXO Good Grips justifies its $54.95 price tag with a brilliant pull-out display and an easy-to-clean stainless steel surface. It looks great on any counter.
Premium Pick
9/10
The My Weigh KD-8000 costs $51.97 and prioritizes raw accuracy over aesthetics. You get a baker-focused tool that handles heavy daily use without breaking a sweat.
OXO Good Grips Kitchen Scale
Why Choose OXO Good Grips Kitchen Scale
- Pull-out display remains visible under 12-inch mixing bowls.
- Stainless steel platform pops off for easy sink washing.
- Slim 1.1-inch profile slides easily into shallow kitchen drawers.
- 11-pound capacity handles standard dinner prep.
My Weigh KD-8000
Why Choose My Weigh KD-8000
- 8,000-gram (17.6 lb) capacity easily holds heavy ceramic bowls.
- Programmable auto-off can be disabled entirely.
- Built-in baker’s math function calculates hydration percentages.
- Registers micro-adjustments instantly.
OXO Good Grips Kitchen Scale
Potential Downsides
- Auto-off timer triggers too quickly during complex recipes.
- Struggles to register single-gram additions of lightweight ingredients.
- Higher price point for a basic digital scale.
My Weigh KD-8000
Potential Downsides
- Bulky, industrial footprint eats up cabinet space.
- Hinged acrylic screen cover traps flour dust.
- AC power adapter is often sold separately.
Design & Build Quality
The OXO Good Grips features a smudge-resistant stainless steel finish that actually stays clean. It feels solid and sits just 1.1 inches high, meaning you can slide it into a drawer alongside your cutting boards. You will love the pull-out display when weighing ingredients in oversized mixing bowls. Pull the screen out, and a 12-inch bowl won’t cast a shadow over your measurements.
The My Weigh KD-8000 takes a completely different approach. It looks like a piece of industrial lab equipment. You sacrifice counter appeal for a highly functional, bulky plastic body that withstands heavy abuse. It takes up significantly more vertical space, and the hinged acrylic faceplate over the buttons tends to trap stray flour. Buy the OXO for sleek storage. Choose the My Weigh for utility.
Features & Performance
You can remove the OXO platform entirely to wash it in the sink. This makes cleaning up sticky dough incredibly easy. The zero function responds instantly. However, the OXO struggles with micro-adjustments. When I slowly tapped active dry yeast into a bowl, the OXO wouldn’t register the change until about three grams hit the platform. It also features a strict auto-off timer that will shut down and erase your tare weight if you take too long grabbing your next ingredient.
The My Weigh KD-8000 wins on pure measurement accuracy and baker-specific features. It registered single-gram micro-adjustments of yeast and salt that the OXO missed entirely. More importantly, the KD-8000 allows you to disable the auto-off feature completely, so your scale stays on while you knead or wait for a resting phase. It also includes a baker’s percentage function, letting you calculate water and salt ratios directly on the screen based on your total flour weight.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you disable the auto-off feature on these scales?
You can disable the auto-off on the My Weigh KD-8000, which is a massive advantage for bakers who need the scale to stay on while prepping multiple ingredients. The OXO Good Grips has a fixed auto-off timer that cannot be changed or disabled.
What is the maximum weight capacity?
The My Weigh KD-8000 holds up to 8,000 grams (about 17.6 pounds), making it ideal for heavy glass bowls or Dutch ovens. The OXO Good Grips maxes out at 11 pounds (roughly 5,000 grams).
Conclusion: Our Final Verdict
Buy the My Weigh KD-8000 if you bake sourdough and need exact gram measurements. Choose the OXO Good Grips if you just portion daily meals. Check the current prices below to make your final choice.
